HomeServicesAboutContact Call 631-736-7255

Out of the Oven

Everything, sesame, pumpernickel — still warm when the doors open.

The Breakfast Rush

Bacon-egg-and-cheese on a fresh everything. Selden runs on it.

Selden's morning ritual

Boiled. Baked. Gone by Noon.

Real kettle-boiled bagels out of the oven every morning, whipped cream cheeses, and breakfast sandwiches worth setting an alarm for.

Scroll

What we do

Everything Strathmore does best

From everyday favorites to special occasions — this is what Selden keeps coming back for.

Fresh-Baked Bagels Daily

Fresh-Baked Bagels Daily

Kettle-boiled and baked in-house every morning — everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, and more.

Learn more →
Breakfast Sandwiches

Breakfast Sandwiches

Bacon, egg & cheese, sausage, Taylor ham — on the bagel of your choice, made to order.

Learn more →
Flavored Cream Cheeses

Flavored Cream Cheeses

Whipped fresh: scallion, veggie, strawberry, lox spread, and the classics.

Learn more →
Catering & Dozens

Catering & Dozens

Bagel dozens, cream cheese tubs, and breakfast spreads for offices and morning meetings.

Learn more →
Coffee & Espresso

Coffee & Espresso

Hot coffee, iced coffee, and espresso drinks to go with the bagel.

Learn more →
Lunch Sandwiches & Wraps

Lunch Sandwiches & Wraps

Boar's Head cold cuts stacked on fresh rolls and wraps when the morning rush winds down.

Learn more →

By the numbers

Strathmore at a glance

0 Bagel Varieties
0 Star Morning Rating
0 Guest Reviews
0 Doors Open Daily

* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration purposes.

The difference

Before & after

Drag the handle to compare — this is the Strathmore difference.

Day-old grocery bagels
Hot out of the oven
↔
Before After

How it works

Easy as one, two, three

  1. Beat the Rush

    Doors open early — the everything bagels go first, every single day.

  2. Pick Your Bagel

    Twenty-plus varieties, still warm. Toasted or not, that's your call.

  3. Load It Up

    Whipped cream cheese, lox spread, or the full bacon-egg-and-cheese treatment.

  4. Grab a Dozen

    One for now, eleven for later — or the whole box for the office.

Kind words

What Selden says

★★★★★

“The everything bagel here is the real deal — chewy, salty, perfect. I drive past three other shops to get here.”

— Morning regular, Selden

★★★★★

“Ordered five dozen plus spreads for an office meeting. Showed up early, everything was ready and warm.”

— Office manager, Coram

★★★★★

“Bacon-egg-and-cheese on a fresh sesame is my Saturday religion now.”

— Weekend regular, Farmingville

* Representative guest feedback shown for demonstration.

Good to know

Questions, answered

Early — the ovens run before sunrise so bagels are fresh when the doors open. Call 631-736-7255 for today's exact hours.

Yes — kettle-boiled and baked in-house every single morning. When a variety sells out, it's gone until tomorrow.

Absolutely — dozens, cream cheese tubs, and full breakfast spreads. Call ahead at 631-736-7255 for large orders.

Call ahead to ask about current gluten-free selections — availability varies daily.

Yes — free plaza parking at 351 Independence Plaza.

Yes — Boar's Head sandwiches and wraps join the menu after the morning rush.

Proudly serving

Your neighborhood, our home

Strathmore serves Selden and these surrounding Long Island communities.

Ready when you are

Experience Strathmore for yourself

Real kettle-boiled bagels out of the oven every morning, whipped cream cheeses, and breakfast sandwiches worth setting an alarm for.

Call Now Directions