
Fresh-Baked Bagels Daily
Kettle-boiled and baked in-house every morning — everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, and more.
Learn more →Everything, sesame, pumpernickel — still warm when the doors open.
Bacon-egg-and-cheese on a fresh everything. Selden runs on it.
Selden's morning ritual
Real kettle-boiled bagels out of the oven every morning, whipped cream cheeses, and breakfast sandwiches worth setting an alarm for.
What we do
From everyday favorites to special occasions — this is what Selden keeps coming back for.

Kettle-boiled and baked in-house every morning — everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, and more.
Learn more →
Bacon, egg & cheese, sausage, Taylor ham — on the bagel of your choice, made to order.
Learn more →
Whipped fresh: scallion, veggie, strawberry, lox spread, and the classics.
Learn more →
Bagel dozens, cream cheese tubs, and breakfast spreads for offices and morning meetings.
Learn more →

Boar's Head cold cuts stacked on fresh rolls and wraps when the morning rush winds down.
Learn more →By the numbers
* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration purposes.
The difference
Drag the handle to compare — this is the Strathmore difference.

How it works
Doors open early — the everything bagels go first, every single day.
Twenty-plus varieties, still warm. Toasted or not, that's your call.
Whipped cream cheese, lox spread, or the full bacon-egg-and-cheese treatment.
One for now, eleven for later — or the whole box for the office.
Kind words
* Representative guest feedback shown for demonstration.
Good to know
Early — the ovens run before sunrise so bagels are fresh when the doors open. Call 631-736-7255 for today's exact hours.
Yes — kettle-boiled and baked in-house every single morning. When a variety sells out, it's gone until tomorrow.
Absolutely — dozens, cream cheese tubs, and full breakfast spreads. Call ahead at 631-736-7255 for large orders.
Call ahead to ask about current gluten-free selections — availability varies daily.
Yes — free plaza parking at 351 Independence Plaza.
Yes — Boar's Head sandwiches and wraps join the menu after the morning rush.
Proudly serving
Strathmore serves Selden and these surrounding Long Island communities.
Ready when you are
Real kettle-boiled bagels out of the oven every morning, whipped cream cheeses, and breakfast sandwiches worth setting an alarm for.